Insurance agency marketing · pay per lead
Insurance quote requests nobody else bought, billed only when you approve them.
A fast insurance agency website, coverage pages and your Google Business Profile for a $490 founding-partner setup. After launch you pay only for quote requests and calls you approve, and none of them are sold to another agent.
$490 founding-partner setup, $99 a month, first three approved leads free. One insurance agency per city.
$30
per approved insurance agents lead, published before you sign
RankMeHi partner terms, confirmed 27 Sep 2026
26%
have no tap-to-call link on the homepage
RankMeHi study of 662 Orange County business websites. Crawl 25 to 26 Sep 2026; PageSpeed Insights, mobile, 26 Sep 2026.
79%
of sites take more than 4 seconds to show their main content on a phone
RankMeHi study of 662 Orange County business websites. Crawl 25 to 26 Sep 2026; PageSpeed Insights, mobile, 26 Sep 2026.
Free website audit, no sign-up
Free insurance agency website audit: 7 checks in one minute, no sign-up.
Enter your agency website address and the free audit runs 7 checks on your homepage in about a minute, with no sign-up. Each result sits next to the figure from our study of 662 local business sites, and nothing is stored.
Weighing shared leads? Your own website or a lead marketplace
Why insurance agencies lose calls
What a insurance agency's site has to do differently.
In one lineInsurance Agents marketing from RankMeHi is a site, local SEO and a Business Profile built at cost, billed at $30 per lead the insurance agency approves.
Insurance shoppers move at predictable moments: a renewal that went up, a new car or house, a new business that needs liability cover, or the annual enrolment period for health and Medicare plans. Many of them have already filled in a comparison form and been called by several agents. Someone who searches for a local agent instead wants a person who will compare carriers and pick up the phone at claim time.
So the site we build for an insurance agency is organised by what people are buying, auto, home, business, life and health where you write it, with a short quote request on each page. Independent agencies list the carriers they represent; captive agents describe the company behind them. The service area is where you are licensed, so out-of-state enquiries are never billed.
What we build
Six things every insurance agency site gets, written for your jobs.
- 01
A quote request per line
Auto, home, renters, business, life and health, each with the few details you need to start a quote and nothing more.
- 02
Carriers you represent
For an independent agency, the carriers you can quote; for a captive agent, the company and what it offers.
- 03
Business insurance by trade
Contractors, restaurants, retail or whichever trades you write, with the coverage each one usually asks about.
- 04
Enrolment season pages
Medicare and health enrolment dates and what to bring to a review, if you write those lines.
- 05
Claims help
How you help a client through a claim, which is the reason many people want a local agent at all.
- 06
Licences and approvals
Your licence numbers, licensed states and any wording your carrier or regulator requires, on every page.
What you pay for
What counts as a insurance agents lead, and what never does.
Billed at $30
- A household in a state you are licensed in calls for an auto and home quote, and the call runs over a minute
- A quote request from a contractor who needs general liability cover and is not a current client
Never billed
- An existing policyholder reporting a claim or paying a bill
- A carrier or wholesaler rep calling about appointments
- A producer or customer service rep asking about a job
- Anything you reject within seven days, one tap, no reason needed
- Your first three approved leads
Health and individual plans
Health and individual plan leads for an insurance agency
For a health insurance agency, RankMeHi builds a page for individual and family plans, open enrolment dates and special enrolment events such as losing employer cover, moving or having a baby. Each page ends in a short quote request that asks for a name, a phone number, a ZIP code and the plan type, and never an SSN.
The page also lists the carriers you represent in the states where you are licensed, and explains in plain words what you do for the client after enrolment, such as renewals and claims questions.
Who is a billable leadA new individual, family or small-group prospect in a state you are licensed in who calls for over 60 seconds, or sends a form describing a real plan need, is a billable health lead once you approve it.
For health and individual plan agents, existing policyholders, carrier reps, job seekers, spam, repeat contacts within 90 days and callers outside your licensed states are never billed.
Life and final expense
Life insurance and final expense leads for an insurance agency
For a life insurance agency, RankMeHi builds separate pages for term life, whole life, final expense and mortgage protection, because each buyer is in a different situation. A family buying cover after a birth reads differently from an older client planning funeral costs.
Each page says who the cover suits, which carriers you quote and what the first call involves. The request form asks for contact details, an age range and the cover type, and never a policy number or an SSN.
Who is a billable leadA new prospect in a state you are licensed in who asks about term, whole life or final expense cover, by a call over 60 seconds or a form describing a real need, is a billable life or final expense lead once you approve it.
For life and final expense agents, existing policyholders, beneficiaries chasing a claim, carrier or wholesaler reps, job seekers, spam and repeat contacts within 90 days are never billed.
Medicare and annual enrolment
Medicare and annual enrolment leads for an insurance agency
For a Medicare insurance agency, RankMeHi builds pages for Medicare Advantage, Medigap and Part D, a turning-65 guide and a page for the annual enrolment period that runs from 15 October to 7 December. The pages explain the dates, what to bring to a plan review and how to book a call with you.
The wording on these pages follows what you and your carriers approve. Nothing about plans or benefits goes live until you approve it, and the form never asks for a Medicare number or an SSN. The lead rules are the same during annual enrolment as the rest of the year.
Who is a billable leadA new person in a state you are licensed in who asks about Medicare plans, by a call over 60 seconds or a form describing a real need such as turning 65 or reviewing a plan during annual enrolment, is a billable Medicare lead once you approve it.
For Medicare agents, existing policyholders, carrier reps, job seekers, spam, repeat contacts within 90 days and anyone outside your licensed states are never billed, during annual enrolment or at any other time.
Cost of a lead
What a insurance agents lead costs, side by side.
| Aspect | Price per lead | Shared with others | You approve first | A site you keep |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shared-lead marketplaces in general | Set by the marketplace | Three to five businesses | No | No |
| Retainer agency | Same fee with or without leads | Usually not | No | Usually |
| RankMeHi pay-per-lead partner | $30, first three free | Never, one partner per city | Yes, seven days | Yes |
Marketplace figures are the public price ranges on their pricing pages, read on 27 September 2026. The RankMeHi price is the published partner rate. Compare cost per lead across trades.
| Aspect | Amount | What it covers | Why it is set this way |
|---|---|---|---|
| Setup, one time | $490 | Your insurance agency website, coverage pages and your Google Business Profile. | It is the build cost. It is paid once and the site is yours to keep. |
| Hosting and call tracking, monthly | $99 a month | Hosting, the tracked phone number with call recording and your lead ledger. | It pays for running the site and the tracking. It is not a marketing retainer and buys no ad management. |
| Each approved lead | $30, written into your agreement before you sign | One new quote request or call you approve. The first three approved leads are free. | Billed only when you approve the lead. $30 is under 5% of an average first policy and at or below the lowest published price for an exclusive web lead, which is what we hold ourselves to. |
| Lead exclusivity | One agency per city | Every lead goes to you alone and is never resold to another agent. | You never compete with another agent for the same prospect. |
| Rejection window | 7 days | You can reject any lead with one tap and you are not billed for it. | You pay only for the leads you approve. |
The $30 per approved lead applies to quote requests and calls for health, life, Medicare and final expense alike, and is fixed in your agreement before you sign.
Proof
What we can show, honestly.
We have not published a result for insurance agencies yet. The lead logs we can show are from a glass company and a collision shop, and the method is the same: a fast site, a tracked number and a form that logs every enquiry. That is why the first partner in each field gets founding terms.
See the lead logs we do haveHow it works
From first call to first lead in 21 days.
- 01
Free audit and a yes or no
Day 1We check your demand, who answers the phone and whether your city is open. You get a written audit of the current site either way.
You getA price per lead in writing, and a straight answer on fit.
- 02
Design and build at cost
Days 2 to 21A five-page site designed in Figma and built on a static stack, with the tracking number, call recording and the quote form wired in. Live within 21 days of receiving your content or the setup is refunded.
You getA fast site that is yours to keep, and a Business Profile pointed at it.
- 03
Leads land in your ledger
From launchEvery call and form arrives within the hour with the recording or the form text attached. Reject anything with one tap within seven days.
You getExclusive leads, and the first three free.
- 04
One invoice a month
MonthlyOne line per approved lead, after the month ends, under the cap you set. New service and area pages are added as the ledger shows what converts.
You getA bill that only grows when the phone rings.
Questions
Questions insurance agencies ask first.
One insurance agency per city. Is yours still open?
First three approved leads free · One partner per trade per city · You own your domain and content from day one
Start with clarity
Check your city and get the insurance agents price in writing.
- 1Share your name, email and website.
- 2We review your current website and SEO foundation.
- 3We reply with the clearest next steps for your business.
Certified partner
Check if your city is open
Name, email and your trade. We reply within one business day with availability and the per-lead price for your trade.




